Unmatched Downtown Sutter Creek Opportunity – Two Homes + Historic Barn + Gardens on a Storybook Setting Just Off Main Street!

Tucked on a quiet lane just a stone's throw from Sutter Creek’s picturesque Main Street, this extraordinary property offers a rare trifecta: a beautifully updated 3BD/2BA main residence, a fully furnished 1BD/1BA cottage, and a 2,500± sq ft historic barn with flexible-use potential—all set on a thoughtfully landscaped lot filled with charm, privacy, and vision.

The main home seamlessly blends vintage character with modern comfort. Original features like 9’ ceilings, vintage beadboard, custom wallpaper, and plantation shutters pair beautifully with upgrades such as new HVAC (2022), 50-year composition roofs (2022), updated electrical (dual 200-amp panels), recessed lighting, and high-efficiency insulation using Eagle Shield aluminum paneling throughout the attic and basement. The gourmet kitchen includes granite countertops, a large under-counter stainless sink, new appliances, and a walk-in pantry/laundry combo. Bathrooms have been completely redone—featuring a vintage Italian tub/shower combo in the master and a walk-in shower in the guest suite.

A city-approved lock-off 1BD/1BA short-term rental with its own exterior entrance and private security deadbolts offers turnkey income potential or space for guests. The ground-level basement—approximately 1,400 sq ft—features built-in shelving, gravel floors, concrete pads, and remains naturally cool year-round, making it ideal for storage, hobbies, or creative use.

The furnished cottage is equally charming, offering granite countertops, a farm-style sink, full kitchen with gas cooktop and appliances, mini-split HVAC (2020), walk-in shower, and a private patio surrounded by fruit trees. Perfect for guests, tenants, or multigenerational living. Off-street parking serves both residences.

The 2,500± sq ft barn is a local landmark with incredible potential. Currently divided into three working spaces and a loft, it has many possibilities. Whether for a future workshop, event space, or boutique business, the barn offers inspiration for creatives or entrepreneurs.

Outside, the grounds feel like a private garden retreat: winding natural slate paths embedded in Elfin Thyme, heirloom roses, flowering vines, and mature fruit trees including apples, cherries, citrus, figs, and persimmons. A hand-dug artesian well provides irrigation for multiple raised garden beds and a new 2025 drip system. Enjoy sunny afternoons under the shade sails, evenings around the BBQ on a new concrete pad, or stroll the thoughtfully terraced yard framed by historic trees and concrete curbing.

Additional highlights include Ring security systems on both homes, updated fencing and gates, and extensive foundation upgrades. The charm, functionality, and flexibility of this property are unmatched in one of California’s most walkable and sought-after Gold Country towns.

Live, invest, create—this is downtown Sutter Creek at its very best.