126 South Midway Road , Shelter Island, New York

House for Sale in Shelter Island

126 South Midway Road , Shelter Island, NY

  • CA$4,163,610
  • 6 BEDS
  • 4+2 BATHS
  • 0.90 ac Land
  • CA$4,163,610

House for Sale in Shelter Island

126 South Midway Road , Shelter Island, NY

  • CA$4,163,610
  • 6 BEDS
  • 4+2 BATHS
  • 0.90 ac Land
  • CA$4,163,610

Key Facts

  • MLS® #: 928253
  • Property ID: SIRC3088464
  • Original Price: USD 3,300,000
  • Property Type: Residential, Single Family Detached
  • Lot Size: 0.90 ac
  • Year Built: 1999
  • Bedrooms: 6
  • Bathrooms: 4+2

Property Description

Architecturally distinctive and deeply connected to its coastal setting, 126 South Midway Road is a private compound that captures the spirit of Shelter Island's artistic legacy. A private sanctuary comprising a four-bedroom main residence, a dedicated large art studio, and an independent two-bedroom casita, the property is thoughtfully arranged to maximize natural light, privacy, and sweeping water views. The architecture recalls relaxed modernism of iconic beach houses, an approach rooted in simplicity, creativity, and a fluid relationship with the landscape. Clean lines, a sleek pool and an intuitive indoor-outdoor flow create spaces that feel both intentional and effortlessly livable, ideal for a design-minded coastal lifestyle. The separate studio enhances the compound's creative sensibility, offering a quiet, light-filled environment for work or reflection, while the two-bedroom casita provides comfortable, private accommodations for guests or extended stays. Together, the structures form a cohesive yet flexible retreat, equally suited to intimate living and hosting. Comprised of 3,400 sq. feet living space across 3 levels in the main house plus additional storage, an expansive art studio of 1,400 sq. ft and 2-bedroom Casita living 1,140 sq feet with multiple decks and outdoor entertaining spaces this incredible compound is moments from Wades Beach. The property offers a rare combination of architectural character and proximity to one of Shelter Island's most celebrated shorelines. Longtime Shelter Island residents David Rankin OAM and Lily Brett OAM, both internationally recognized for their contributions to the visual arts and literature, have stewarded the home with a deep appreciation for creativity and place. (OAM denotes the Order of Australia Medal, a national honor recognizing distinguished contribution.) A compelling offering for those drawn to thoughtful design, privacy, and coastal modernism, 126 South Midway Road is a singular Shelter Island retreat.

Open House

Amenities

  • Basement - Finished
  • Central Air
  • Hardwood Floors
  • Library
  • River View

Listing Agents

  • Jenny Landey

    C. 9177432525

    O. 6313246000

  • Maz Crotty

    C. 6463220223

    O. 6312274947

Ask Us For More Information

*Showing requires confirmation from agent.

Ask Us For More Information

*Showing requires confirmation from agent.

Location

126 South Midway Road , Shelter Island, New York, 11964 United States

Around this property

Information about the area within a 5-minute walk of this property.

Request Neighbourhood Information

Learn more about the neighbourhood and amenities around this home

Request Now

Marketed By

Sotheby's International Realty - East Hampton Brokerage
6 Main Street
East Hampton, New York, 11937
United States

6313246000

Similar PropertiesSee All Similar Properties

Home/United States/New York/Shelter Island/MLS® 928253